The Babocomari Bridge was constructed in 1922 and is ‘potentially’ eligible for the Historic Register. (PRT file photo)

In a summary of findings prepared for Santa Cruz County on the  Babocomari/Elgin Bridge, HDR Engineering Inc. outlined costs associated with each of the four options being considered and evaluated the implications of each alternative.

The bridge, an iconic 1922 structure, is scheduled to be replaced in 2027 using $3.9 million received through the federal Off-System Bridge Program. The one-lane span crossing Babocomari Creek remains one of a small number of surviving examples of a Warren steel half-through truss bridge in Arizona.

Elgin resident Sue Downing has been advocating for keeping the bridge as a pedestrian/bicycle crossing and the heart of a new community park, with the construction of a new bridge at a different site.  

The four options currently being considered by the county include:

  • Option 1: Do nothing
  • Option 2: Construct a new bridge at a new location/alignment
  • Option 3: Rehabilitate existing bridge
  • Option 4: Construct a new bridge at the current bridge’s location

Option 1: County officials have said this is not an option. Public safety is at stake as it relates to both the bridge’s current weight capacity and its alignment with Upper Elgin Road.

As to the integrity of the bridge itself, HDR engineering has rated the deck as “good,” the substructure as “fair” and the superstructure as “poor.” The superstructure directly carries traffic loads. The current posted capacity of the bridge is 10 tons. Arizona’s legal bridge load limit is 40 tons.

Under the “do nothing” plan, normal maintenance would continue but would not “address the underlying corrosion-related deficiencies affecting the bridge’s structural components.” The HDR report also noted that the condition of the bridge would be expected to “decline over time, increasing maintenance demands and associated costs.”

Option 2: According to the HDR report, a new bridge could be constructed 65 feet south of the existing bridge. The two-way traffic span could accommodate legal highway traffic loads, but it would require a larger footprint, including the removal of mature cottonwood trees. “Following completion … the old bridge would remain in place and continue to require ownership, inspection, maintenance and long-term preservation commitments.”

Anticipated construction cost: $3,418,000

Below the line costs (contingencies, construction engineering and post-design services): $1,302,000

Total project cost: $4,720,00

Not included: Future maintenance costs associated with the historic bridge.

Option 3: HDR put forth two rehabilitation schemes – conventional and unconventional. Conventional rehabilitation would be time-consuming, complex and costly and was not considered feasible. Unconventional would require micropiles to support a new reinforced concrete slab spanning the creek. (Micropiles are small, deep-foundational elements that support loads in tight spaces or difficult soil conditions.) This approach would require the closing of the bridge during construction and the development of a detour route. While the bridge is not currently on the Historic Register, the State Historic Preservation Office would “likely” need to be consulted on this option, as the bridge is “potentially” eligible and the preservation or original engineering characteristics would need to be examined.

Worth noting: The bridge would remain a single-lane crossing and would require ongoing inspection, maintenance and preservation. It would, however, address the current load limit.

Anticipated construction cost: $2,244,000. This represents a decrease of about $1,451,000 compared to the initial replacement alternative.

Option 4: When Santa Cruz County approached the federal government in funding a new bridge, the Babocomari span was not considered eligible for the National Register. As reevaluation shows it being potentially eligible, scrutiny of its potential demolition has increased.

While an aesthetic rendering of the new bridge has not been released, the HDR report noted it “most closely matches the look of the existing bridge.” The new span would accommodate two-way traffic and legal loads. It would not, however, solve the alignment issue, according to HDR documentation.

“This design would result in an adverse effect to the Babocomari Creek Bridge, an NRHP eligible property and Section 4(f) property,” the report states. A 4(f) property is a protected piece of public land or historic site that the U.S. government guards against damage or takeover by federally funded transportation project.

Anticipated construction cost: $2,673,000

Below the line costs (contingencies, construction engineering and post-design services): $1,022,000

Total project cost: $3,695,000

Summary of Evaluated Alternatives

Evaluation Criteria1-Do nothing2-New location / alignment3-Bridge rehabilitation4-Current replacement concept
Retains Historic BridgeYESYESYESNO
Accommodates Two-Way TrafficNOYESNOYES
Addresses Existing Structural DeficienciesNOYESYESYES
Avoids Long-Term Maintenance of Historic BridgeNONONOYES
Avoids Construction DetourYESYESNONO
Avoids Right-of-Way AcquisitionsYESNOYESNO
Fits Within Current Project FundingNONOYESYES
Meets Project GoalsNOYESPARTIALLYYES

Source: HDR Engineering

“No matter what direction we go, there are going to be some people who are upset,” said John Fanning, District 3 Supervisor, during a recent community check-in in Elgin. He understands the passion that this topic evokes but knows “sometimes you have to make a tough decision.”

The Arizona Department of Transportation serves as administrator on this project. The agency is facing a September 2027 deadline in assigning the federal monies. Unallocated, those dollars revert back to the federal government.