Public input: That is what John Fanning is hoping to garner from the Babocomari Bridge Open House scheduled for Tuesday, Sept. 1, from 9 to 11 a.m. at the Elgin Club.

Concrete bridge with signs posted and trees on either side.
The Babocomari Bridge was constructed in 1922 and is limited in its capacity to handle current traffic loads. (Photo by Carrie White)

“I want to hear from everyone,” said Fanning, Santa Cruz County District 3 Supervisor. “I want to hear if people support it and if they don’t support it, why not. But first and foremost, I want to make sure they (the public) understand that nothing is set in stone.”

The single-lane Warren pony truss bridge, referred to as both the Babocomari Bridge and Elgin Bridge, was constructed in 1922 to connect Upper Elgin Road over Babocomari Creek. In 2022 an ADOT report cited the bridge’s integrity as “poor,” and $3.9 million were secured for its 2027 replacement through the federal Off-System Bridge Program.

Since then, the bridge has been reevaluated for potential preservation as part of the Arizona Department of Transportation’s National Register of Historic Place Program.

Inclusion on the Register would not guarantee its survival, but it requires ADOT to go through a federal evaluation process to assess how government-funded or permitted projects might affect historic properties and archaeological resources. That process is currently ongoing.

For the open house, illustrated stations on the bridge will be set up with county officials present to answer questions and discuss the timetable of events that brought the project to this juncture.

“We’re also going to take a look at potential alternatives associated with this project,” Fanning said. Three different options are scheduled to be showcased.

Replacement of the bridge has generated vocal opposition from those looking to save the historic bridge. While critics of the new construction understand the need for a two-lane bridge that can withstand greater loads and has a safer alignment with intersecting roadways, alternatives have been proposed that would allow the preservation of the historic bridge as a pedestrian/bicycle crossing and centerpiece for a community park.

A new bridge site and necessary detours would require the purchase of land from owners of neighboring property. Fanning said the county has been in contact with a representative of the descendants of Patricia L. Lareau who inherited the property upon her passing.

“I know there are some folks out there that feel that everything is a done deal already. That’s not the case,” Fanning said. “This is a chance to get public feedback. That’s what we are looking for.”   

The Babocomari Bridge Open House will immediately follow the Elgin Community Check-In, at which Fanning will be available to meet with constituents from 8 to 9 a.m. at the Elgin Club.